Our history
The Pfenninger Agency, Inc. is the oldest insurance company in Henry County, Indiana. We have proudly served our clients since 1902. The Pfenninger Agency was started by J.J. Pfenninger, and is currently being run by a third generation of Pfenningers. The Agency prides itself on ethics and customer satisfaction, and its ability to customize insurance plans because of it being an independent insurance agency. Steve Pfenninger, owner of the Pfenninger Agency, is the only agent in Henry County to be designated both CPCU and CLU. The Pfenninger Agency is licensed to serve customers across the states of Indiana, Ohio, and Florida.

Independent agents
As an independent insurance agency, we are here to help you with all of your insurance questions. Our mission is to help you manage the risks you face. We can furnish you with an assessment of your insurance needs and offer you a choice of insurance products to meet those needs.

Most importantly, we are committed to providing you with prompt, quality service if you have a claim.

Just as important is the level of professional confidence and personal comfort you feel with a particular agency. Many people stick with the same insurance agency for decades -- even generations. It helps to find an agency that you can get to know and trust.

You can be sure you are dealing with an independent insurance agency when you see the Big "I" logo on our signs, letterhead, business cards, and even on our Web site. Or ask if the agency is a member of the Independent Insurance Agents of America -- the oldest and largest association of independent insurance agents, representing a network of 300,000 agents and agency employees nationwide.