The Pfenninger Agency, Inc.

Located in New Castle, Indiana, The Pfenninger Agency has served clients across the midwestern United States since 1902. We are a full-service professional independent insurance agency offering many forms of insurance including business property, liability, automobile, workers compensation, inland marine, group life and health insurance, personal homeowners, automobile, life, health, and annuities, as well as other forms of insurance and financial planning. Unlike "captive agents" who only represent one company, our agency gives you a choice of insurance companies so that we can tailor fit your needs to the right insurance company. We offer you appropriate coverage with competitive prices. Choose the agency with 100 years of experience to serve you.


Keystone GroupTrusted Choice
Agency Services
Personal Property WizardHow much would it cost to replace your home's contents? Do you need to customize your insurance to protect valuable items? Find out with our wizard.
Personal Risk WizardThings change and your insurance protection should keep up. Our wizard will help you review your risks and evaluate your insurance needs in just a few minutes.